Greatest Hits:: VIXX: On and On
I promised that I'd do a VIXX post, didn't I? After all, what would Halloween be without the original Concept Kings? If you were to have a list of Halloween appropriate songs and it wasn't half-filled with VIXX songs, I'd be confused. In this case, I have a special fondness for this song because I keep singing part of it during my D&D games because it's wholly appropriate for our poor characters. Also, if anyone needs the range of concept that VIXX pulled out, the last post I did for the whole group was VOODOO DOLL, where they were trapped dolls in their own rooms of torment and external control. What is it this time? A lot of fun.
VIXX debuted in 2012 as a six-member group under Jellyfish Entertainment. Most of their songs so far have been with the six of them, and considering how early this one is, it wouldn't be surprising that this one is with all six. Which it is. Also, all six of them are over 180cm, so they're also fairly tall. The more you learn.
On and On was the eponymous title track of their third single, 다칠 준비가 돼 있어, and later released as part of their first album. As the sole lyricist, we have Kim Eana (IVE, Sam Kim, Unnies, IU, Taeyeon, Suzy, Sung Si Kyung, Park Hyo Shin, (VIXX: VOODOO DOLL) Brown Eyed Girls (Abracadabra and Paradise Lost), SHINee, EXO, BOYNEXTDOOR, Zion.T, MAMAMOO, Billlie, Kiss of Life, Jaessbee, Ailee, Park Hyo Shin, Baby DONT Cry, K.Will, Onew, Monsta X, Younha, RIIZE, OH MY GIRL, Kim Bumsoo, Lovelyz, Pentagon, BIGBANG, Seo In Guk, WJSN, STAYC, Rania, Shinhwa, G Wannabe, GFRIEND, Lim Young Woong, Sechskies, Weeekly, HELLOVENUS, 24K, ZE:A, Uhm Jung Hwa, fromis_9, History, Sunny Hill, Lee Hyori, DinDin, BoA, DXMON, Rainbow Blaxx, Wonder Girls, Hynn, 100%, Infinite, SS501, Eric Nam, miss A, Kassy, f(x), BLACKSWAN, Fiestar, F-ve Dolls, TVXQ!, Davichi, Jewelry, JeA, Bada, Tahiti, Kim Dong Wan, and A'ST1). Our composers are Hwang Se Jun (also the founder of Jellyfish) (Sung Si Kyung, G.NA, OH MY GIRL, fromis_9, LUCY, Papaya, Jang Hey Jin, Jeon Hye Bin, Kim Min Jong, Seo In Guk, Brian Joo, Sojung, Click-B, Roy Kim, Left Turn, Apple, 2AM, and Lee Ji Hoon), Mussashi (Red Velvet, Arashi, SHINee, Girls' Generation, aespa, TWICE, EXO, The Boyz, CNBLUE, ZE:A, Queenz Eye, gugudan, SF9, Victon, N.Flying, TVXQ!, BoA, After School, and HOTSHOT), Rick Hanley (EXO, Girls' Generation, BoA, TVXQ!, Super Junior, and Block B), and Kirstine Lindemann (gugudan and GEM).
- Group: VIXX (Voice, Visual, Value in Excelsis)
- Debut Date: 2012 May 24
- Company: Jellyfish Entertainment
- Status: Active
- Album: On and On
- Song: On and On
- Release Date: 2013 January 17
I deeply hope you all also get "I need therapy, la la la la la therapy" stuck in your heads. It has been an earworm for me for like three years, which isn't that long, but it is basically the same amount of time since the first time I heard it. Which is also why that's the part I keep singing under my breath for D&D because our poor characters are having to go on a second vacation in the space of a week to deal.
Alright. Anyway. Back to business. This was the start of their Concept Kings era and you cannot get much more high concept than this. Vampires on the moon. Whoever came up with this needs a raise. Which is funny because you can actually hear some howling at :04 and at :19. You absolutely could believe that they're werewolves because of it.
Also, listen to how dramatically cinematic that intro is. The entire song is doing all the work it could possibly do, but that intro is an entirely different beast. Pun slightly intended. I also just got distracted by learning something about this song, specifically the intro, and then going and looking for proof, which I found in the dance practice and a couple of the stages. So I'm lampshading that change while we focus on the song as it exists today.
For the record, the Korean title of the song "다칠 준비가 돼 있어" translates to "I'm ready to get hurt", which makes this the second of VIXX's songs that I've done for one of these that is potentially problematic in the "this is a red flag relationship" sort of way. "They say she's dangerous, but I can't hear them". The good news is that this one recognizes that there's a problem because of the aforementioned "I need therapy, la la la la la therapy" line. The first step to fixing a problem is acknowledging that there is a problem to be fixed.
You know, one thing that I appreciate about VIXX songs, especially the earlier ones since we're looking at a song released while they were still in their first year, is that they don't pretend to be nonchalant. And I can't decide if I mean that more in terms of the music or the music video.
Like, the music video starts off with that dystopia beige that the teen dystopia movies had in abundance during this time. But that dystopia beige is also tied up in army brown because of the soldiers who bundle our lovely chained up vampires and launch them in rockets to the moon, to go rescue a girl like they're the Suicide Squad.
Naturally, they must be shirtless while in the rockets, until the rockets crash, and then they've got shirts on when they stand up. Shirts and not a soot stain or burn to be seen. And then as soon as they stand up and get their bearings, it is time to dance! Dramatically!
While that's going on, the vocals are going off like rent is due, which it could have been given the state of a lot of companies in 2013, the rapping is stare-down-a-barrel intense, and the way the instrumental abruptly cuts off only to restart like a punch to the face helps to drive this song into hootin' and hollerin' territory, which I believe is the scientific term.
And that's ignoring the ad-libs that I'm pretty sure are buried through the entire song but are definitely at minimum wandering about the end of the song.
You know what? I'm going to do something odd with this post and I'm not going to give you a music stage first. Because I want to show off what excellent second gen vocals sounded like. How does On and On completely a cappella sound?
Stunning, is the actual answer.
I believe the a cappella group singing with them is called Maytree and they're amazing in their own right and now I'm seriously considering covering one of their songs because I cannot express to you how much I love a cappella. But they're not the focus here. (Although I have to be delighted by the gentleman at 1:06 because that's a gorgeous bass voice he's got there).
The focus is Ken at 1:34 where he lets his voice just go and the raw vibrato there, on Ravi at 2:18 when he hits that rap like a car on black ice (without the inherent danger of skidding out of control because he is fully in control), and on the tendons standing out on Leo's neck and the distance of the mic from his mouth at :47.
Even without the special effects and the stylistic autotune, those three slam into this song with the heft of a wrecking ball. Leo and Ken go after those ad-libs at 2:30 like it's their full-time job. Forget being idols and dancing, they're on the ad-libs like they've never heard of dancing.
And you know what's more incredible? Those three don't have a single in-ear in. Leo's got one, but he's got it out on his shoulder. Some of the Maytree members have in-ears in (one of them takes his out at :37), but not an ear is filled for these three idols.
This isn't a criticism of the Maytree members. Good for them for using the in-ears for whatever reason. It's just deeply impressive that the idols, who as a group regularly get looked down on for not being real singers or real rappers or real dancers, are doing this without any external support other than the other voices.
Alright, Champions. For your [my] benefit, I decided to go dig into the types of performances because I wanted to know some information about MR, AR, LAR, and LMR performances. Because we here at this blog want truth, even when it is unpleasant (which is also why I look for physical evidence on top of the audible evidence for live singing). The answer is: by Covid, they'd stopped being secret and started being widespread enough that most performances were and now are LAR or LMR (which means recorded with "live" vocals (AKA imperfections and breathing) and fully lip synced, or partially lip synced and partially truly live).
We've actually seen that in a few of these posts, where I've noted spots that are definitely lip synced because there is an audible difference in other spots or other stages.
I also learned that Music Core requires the artists to record when they get there and encourages them to sing over the vocals, which is why Music Core performances often sound different compared to other music shows. But what we're not here to do is do a witch hunt on whether or not idols sing live, which is why we do not deliberately track across music shows. If I see enough evidence and I hear enough evidence, I'm willing to tag the artist as "at least partially live" and move on, even if I don't say anything. If I don't get my evidence satisfactorily, then I don't mention it and move on.
Why did we just have three paragraphs on the potential validity of live performances? Because Leo right at the beginning goes a little wonky with his vocals on "달아나고 있어" at :22 and I thought to myself "What are the odds that they'd started in on the LAR and LMR like we have now?" The answer is: "It's possible, but somewhat unlikely," especially since this is 2013 and before the Chief Producer made his comments.
This is my life. I go down rabbit holes of discovery and you all get to reap the benefits.
But we do know that Leo has some stunning, gorgeous live vocals per the a cappella performance you've already seen. That man can sing. Also, the mics are probably at least live anyway because at 2:04, one of them shouts "Huh!" I suspect it may have been Ravi.
Also, because we're not going to get this part during the dance practice, can I just point out how very vampire they are at the beginning? The dancers help them rise up like they're coming up out of coffins, arms crossed over their chests and fingers curved into claws and everything. The music video itself isn't particularly "vampire", so it's nice to see the concept shine through in the stages, where the choreography makes the styling look like the vampire concept as well. The contacts especially really help with that.
And I adore that when we get the line "I'm on my knees again", the choreography has everyone but Hongbin (who is the one singing that line) drop to their knees. I'm not sure what exactly that's called, but when music follows the visuals on the screen in movies, that's called Mickey Mousing. It's not an exact equivalent, but it's close enough that I think it's probably in the same topical family.
We're hopping over to Show Champion for the next stage.
Can we take a moment to appreciate the vampire stuff going on in the LED screen? We've got the normal cemetery stuff with bats and big crosses and that would be enough, but then during the chorus, we get a big full moon and spooky, ruined, Gothic architecture.
And hilariously, one of the Starlights in the audience at :30 sounds almost exactly like the Wilhelm scream, which I predominately have associated with vampires because it's in the first episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. It actually shows up quite a lot in that show.
Now, I'm not sure which one he is, because apparently this bit of the song is all of them singing and I don't know their individual voices well enough, other than Ravi because reasons I'll get into in a moment, to be able to tell you specifically which one I'm hearing this from (other than my guess that it's either Ken or Leo just because they're the main vocalists). But whoever that is at 1:46 is managing to pull out the vibrato on a part that from a less vocally proficient group wouldn't even be a dream of having vibrato there.
(Also, obviously VIXX was an inspiration behind the Saja Boys)
One of the things that makes VIXX stand out like they do, even with the deluge of 2012 boy groups, is their total commitment to the concept. Ravi actually pulled out a growl to his voice, which already is low and husky, for his opening bit that I'm not going to bother time stamping because if you hit play at the start of the video, you will hear it. He's also got his bright orange hair styled like backwards cockatoo head feathers, but somehow it manages to add to the visual rather than make him look completely bizarre because there is no visible self-consciousness, just total commitment regardless of how silly he could be looking.
Hey, so remember how we just had three paragraphs talking about likelihood of live vocals because this is 2013 and you can tell when there are live vocals versus lip syncing? And how sometimes performances are a bit mixed?
I think this performance is one of the best examples to give for a mixed performance, and unfortunately part of that is because these guys seem so exhausted that I just want to go back in time and give them a hug. Maybe after they towel off though.
This is episode 112 of Simply K-Pop, which actually aired in 2014, so over a year after this song was released. I'm not sure why this was the one that they performed then, when VOODOO DOLL was a much closer release, but, whatever. It is what it is. Their costumes have the VOODOO DOLL oversized stitching though, so that's really fun. There are two members missing in performance: Hyuk (filming Law of the Jungle) and Ravi (hurt ankle; he's off to the side in a dark suit). You'll notice that there are still six people performing, because they brought in dancers to fill those spots.
So, with that in mind, I'm going to direct you to the stretch starting with Hongbin at 1:58 through Hyuk's "I need therapy". Hongbin is so wobbly that I refuse to believe that any company would allow a recording that's so imperfect to be one that he's lip-syncing to, since the point of the LAR and LMR is to give as perfect a performance as possible. And then Hyuk's part is so audibly different and sanitized by comparison, but we know that's lip syncing right there, because he's not there and obviously they didn't have one of the other members cover his part.
Normally I'd consider that a reasonable option, but this was two weeks before their comeback for ETERNITY, so I'm actually glad that the company just let the lip syncing happen there rather than pile extra onto any of them.
But even Leo and Ken are unstable in spots. Typically, main vocalists are the most stable vocally, which is one of the reasons the main vocalist is the main vocalist. VIXX has two. Leo lets the backtrack take his first line, and when he comes in, he manages only part of his second. Ken, immediately following him, sings all of his part but is nearly panting through it. I cannot imagine how bad the group's condition as a whole is for the main vocalists to be audibly suffering like this.
And then there's N at :39 who is so shiny with sweat that I'm worried for his electrolyte levels. His hair is sticking to his forehead and he looks like he took an oil dip. N actually sounds quite stable, which is remarkable, but he's also got moments, like at 1:33, where you can hear the voice wobbles from his head being tossed about because of the choreography.
Bear in mind, the eldest is only twenty-three. The thing is that this song is about suffering in love, although it's more of an emotional suffering rather than a physical one, so this stage is unfortunately an excellent embodiment of this. We hear all the time about how much the idols love their fans, and regardless of how much of that is fanservice, this stage hands us some of the cost of that love in raw vocals and effort.
We're going to fast forward a bit, to their Band Live video they did when they started being active as a group again post-military. We're now down to N, Ken, Leo, and Hyuk, but the harmonizing that those four are doing here is phenomenal. I'm not going to give you a time stamp to skip to because the band starts up while they're talking and it's the first song they did. Which is fitting because this song was the beginning of their Concept Kings era.
Also, when they have their next comeback, whenever that is, they need to go on Killing Voice and do this medley properly.
And they're harmonizing specifically on Hyuk's "I need therapy" part, which makes that super cool, and Hongbin's parts shifted to him. I'm not fond of the fact that VIXX has to be four now, but it is what it is. Hyuk looks like a drama (acting) professor in his glasses and the jacket. I'm particularly fond of his line after the therapy part at 1:36. He sounds so good, which is impressive because he's only actually singing one note and it's difficult to maintain that over multiple syllables and stay on pitch instead of going flat. Obviously he's a trained singer, but it's nice to see him be able to do that skill that I would expect him to have. It's like seeing a tennis player with a really good forehand. That's kind of the bread and butter of the sport, but seeing it executed well is just satisfying.
Adorably, N is doing the choreography in tiny while he's singing. He starts that at 1:21. You just get a quick look at him right there because it's a wide shot of all four, before it cuts to a close-up.
I'm slightly swooning over the amount of vibrato that has been presented to us from the four of them. Only slightly. Definitely only a little bit.
I'm perfectly fine and don't want them to come on tour around where I live so that I can pull my earplugs out and have my knees buckle from the gorgeous voices like what definitely did not happen with Seventeen during Candy.
Interestingly, though, if you remember back at the a cappella performance, Ken and Leo had some very nice neck tendon action going on. Ken has clearly had more vocal training since then because if you look at the incredibly clear shot of his neck at 1:14, his tendons are a lot calmer now, but you can still see some tension in his neck muscles. Some, but not a lot. That's evidence of more vocal training, and I'm not surprised by this because he's been doing musicals since 2015, not just his idol job.
I can't do the same comparison with Leo because Leo decided to look like a history professor in his turtleneck. Or his stylist decided to make Leo look like a history professor in his turtleneck. Regardless, the turtleneck hides a lot.
Alright, Champions. Y'all remember how every time I do any post on A.C.E, I start bellowing into the void about how incredible they are?
Back in 2020, A.C.E prepared this stage in three days, as mentioned on the VLive they did afterwards. First of all, there aren't a lot of VIXX covers, which is silly because their discography is ripe for delicious covers. Second of all, A.C.E did what A.C.E does and was incredible (specific shout-out to their stylists for recreating the VIXX look to such detail for a performance seven years to the day after the original). Third of all, Hyuk retweeted this.
Also as a reminder this is the group that had my jaw completely on the ground when I heard them in person. I can't even pretend to be embarrassed about it either.
Listen to the screaming. Listen to the fans. I don't know if the fans are Starlight or Choice or a different fandom entirely, but this performance deserves all of those cheers.
So, we have Wow taking over Ravi's part, Yuchan taking Leo's part, Donghun (now Lee Jiham) taking Ken's part, Junhee taking N's part, and King BK (AKA Kim Byeongkwan) taking Hyuk and Hongbin's parts. You also get the names with who is singing which part courtesy of MCountdown, which is part of the reason why if I can't use a Music Bank performance for the names, I'll often give y'all an MCountdown stage because they usually do.
I particularly like that because Junhee is the leader of A.C.E and he took the leader of VIXX's part. Also, apparently Junhee was originally at Jellyfish as a trainee and his time there overlapped with VIXX's trainee period.
Okay. Some particular highlights from this incredible cover.
Starting at 2:00, Byeongkwan's entire part. The expression on the "다칠 준비가 돼 있어" part while he's in the middle of the rest of the members, the smoothness of the approach so he's in position for the therapy part, and then how cool he looks when he's doing the arms outstretched choreography.
Wow handles Ravi's part so well, between the attitude and the rapid fire rapping. As a note, because the group only has five, they had to use one of the dancers to be the support for his back to help him raise up at the start, but because the dancers are in black, it's actually quite a striking visual. And the immediate pick up of screams at the "Don't let me fall, baby" ad-lib at 2:38 makes me smile. That part is beloved, so I'm happy that he included it.
Donghun at 1:23 is stunning, and I don't know why the close-up of his finger twirling (with the black nail polish of the original) is such a strong detail, but I'm glad that we got that close-up. I'm also glad that we've got that moment at 2:40 where he starts ad-libbing his heart out.
Yuchan (Chan according to the lyrics) adjusts his mic at :29, and the smoothness with which he does it is so natural that I almost missed it the first time and had to go back. He does it again at 1:20 and I literally didn't notice until just now because I was trying to find the precise time stamp for his cool little conducting move at 1:21.
Junhee genuinely looks a little boneless at 1:33, and then he sharpens up his movements so well at 1:35, it makes the contrast more striking. The entire group is sharp right there, but as he's in front, the focus is on him.
I love the comments on this video. It's filled with praise for the five of them and gratitude from the Starlights for covering the song in the first place, especially since 2020 was in an inactive stretch for VIXX.
Dance practice time!
You'll notice that the beginning of the song here is not the fantastic, gloriously dramatic intro that we've been hearing this entire time. Instead, we get the reason why the song had to be changed to avoid copyright issues: the Phantom of the Opera music. Whoever made the new intro did an excellent job of capturing the same epic feeling of something that could be in a musical, but in this case just isn't.
And because the introductory music is different, the opening choreography is different. Here, instead of rising from the coffins with the help of the dancers, the members are laying in a circle around Ravi and rise up out of their coffins on their own. The coffins are of course implied here.
They have wiggly legs and a wiggly body at :43, which is a common theme with this choreography, but it's pretty cool how they go from the sharp synchronized group choreography right there to the wiggly choreography.
And they've got zombie arms and more wiggly legs during the "I need therapy" part at 1:58. I'm telling you: the "I need therapy" part is both an earworm and the gift that keeps on giving.
I happened to pause it at :57 and giggled. Hyuk is levitating with a very serious face and straight legs like he's being raptured. Ravi's stance reminds me of when people would really badly (like, Baby's First Photoshop badly) Photoshop celebrities and movie characters from a still frame and have them move through "scenes" like they're stick puppets. I can practically see the wobbling figure moving across the screen. And then of course at the back, we have N's hair fluffed up and floating above his head to make a gray cloud about him. But I have to compliment Hongbin and Ken because Ken is so perfectly matched to Hongbin's silhouette that I couldn't see him at all and could only see five members.
You want to know something funny too? The most watched part of the video is the very end, starting at the ending pose. Now, I can only guess why here, but we have Leo and N, almost as soon as the song is finished, walking off and leaving (Leo technically first but they are out the door at the same time). Ravi follows close behind. Hyuk takes the time to bow to Hongbin and Ken and the camera before he leaves. Ken and Hongbin also bow before they leave, while we have the sound of panting to follow them out.
And then Hongbin comes back to turn off the camera and we get an extreme close-up of his eye. It's not many dance practices where we get such a good look at an idol's eye.
I'm also going to give you the dance practice with N, Leo, and Ken, minus Hyuk (I believe he was in the military at the time), in 2024 for their fanmeeting or concert or whatever it was. They had to fill the space with dancers, and while it does make me a little sad that it had to happen, it still looks incredible.
Also, it sounds like this might actually be a live dance practice, which is insane, but we are getting at least some live shoe squeaks at minimum. They do have mics though and it sounds like it might be live singing.
Well done, VIXX. Way to continue to be the standard.
Last song for the Halloween season and now we get to move into whatever songs I feel like doing for November. This was a really fun mix and I hope you enjoy the spooks and vampires and witches and ghosts. Expect an odd range in November, and my best friend from high school selected one of them, actually. I was surprised by her choice, but also not surprised that I was surprised.
If you've got any songs you'd like for me to cover, do let me know. Passenger pigeon and smoke rings might be slightly difficult, but I will accept those. The easiest ways are probably either a form of social media or Tumblr, because I do share these on there so if you found this one on one of those, send me a message or a comment. If you'd rather just keep it to here, you can leave a comment here or you can drop a suggestion via The Form.
Happy Halloween, Champions!
Previous: "Villain Dies" by i-dle Next: "Sing For Me" by god (feat. IU)
Comments
Post a Comment